Call Picasso Imports
Checking showroom hours 317-288-4034
Picasso Imports
Menu

Truck buying guide

Best fuel-efficient used trucks: four pickups to compare

Compare four fuel-efficient used trucks with EPA city, highway and combined MPG, fuel costs and towing considerations, then browse Picasso Imports inventory.

Four used trucks worth comparing for fuel economy

The 2022 Ford Maverick hybrid, 2019 Ford Ranger, 2021 Chevrolet Colorado diesel and 2021 Chevrolet Silverado diesel give you four starting points. Among the exact configurations below, the Maverick has the highest EPA combined rating at 37 mpg. Your best choice also depends on purchase price, passenger space, bed fit and the work you need to do.

These are research examples, not a list of trucks currently in stock. All figures are EPA estimates in miles per U.S. gallon. Match the model year, engine, transmission and drive system before applying a rating to a used listing. A different engine or four-wheel-drive version can have a different rating.

EPA fuel economy for four specific used-truck configurations
Vehicle and configurationFuelCity MPGHighway MPGCombined MPG
2022 Ford Maverick HEV — 2.5L four-cylinder hybrid, variable-ratio automatic, FWDRegular gasoline423337
2019 Ford Ranger — 2.3L turbo four-cylinder, 10-speed automatic, RWDRegular gasoline212623
2021 Chevrolet Colorado — 2.8L turbo four-cylinder, 6-speed automatic, RWDDiesel203023
2021 Chevrolet Silverado — 3.0L turbo six-cylinder, 10-speed automatic, RWDDiesel233327

Sources: EPA: 2022 Ford Maverick HEV FWD · EPA: 2019 Ford Ranger 2WD · EPA: 2021 Chevrolet Colorado 2WD diesel · EPA: 2021 Chevrolet Silverado 2WD diesel

Choose a configuration for your driving

Ford Maverick hybrid: start here if city fuel economy is your main comparison. Its 42 city MPG exceeds its 33 highway MPG. Check that this front-wheel-drive configuration, its passenger space and its bed meet your needs before treating the highest combined rating as the deciding factor.

Ford Ranger: this regular-gasoline configuration gives you a 23 combined MPG reference point. Compare its asking price, condition and service records with the other trucks on your shortlist. Use its 21 city and 26 highway ratings to judge how a different mix of driving could affect your budget.

Chevrolet Colorado diesel: its 30 highway MPG makes this configuration worth investigating for a highway-focused comparison. Its 20 city MPG is lower, so do not use the highway figure for every trip. Include the diesel price you would actually pay and the maintenance needs of the individual truck.

Chevrolet Silverado diesel: the listed configuration reaches 27 combined MPG and 33 highway MPG. If you are considering a Silverado, compare this diesel version with other engines using their own EPA records. A favorable MPG figure does not establish the truck's payload or towing rating.

Estimate annual fuel costs using your own prices

Annual fuel cost = annual miles ÷ MPG × price per gallon. For an illustrative 12,000 miles a year at $3.50 per gallon of regular gasoline, the Maverick's 37 combined MPG works out to about $1,135 a year. The Ranger's 23 combined MPG works out to about $1,826.

That is about $691 a year under those assumptions. The $3.50 price is an example, not a current local price or promised fuel bill. Use a diesel price when calculating the Colorado or Silverado, and keep the annual mileage the same when comparing.

Put purchase price, insurance and expected maintenance beside the fuel estimate. A smaller fuel bill might not offset a higher purchase price during your planned ownership period.

Check the truck's condition and working limits

EPA ratings compare vehicles under standardized conditions. Cold weather, short trips, idling, speed, towing and added weight can change fuel use. Check the condition of the tires and ask about modifications. Your normal route and the truck's condition can produce results different from the published rating.

Before choosing, list your passengers, tools, bed cargo and loaded trailer. Check the actual truck's labels and the manufacturer guide for that model year and equipment. Ask for available service records and consider an independent inspection. Use our truck bed length guide below to compare cargo fit alongside fuel economy.

Sources: EPA and DOE: Your Mileage Will Vary · EPA and DOE: Factors That Affect MPG · Ford: towing and payload guidance

Find a used truck and confirm its details

Use the inventory link below and filter by body style to look for trucks. Ask Picasso Imports to confirm the engine, drivetrain, equipment, showroom location and availability of a listing. The four EPA examples above are a comparison guide; our inventory changes and may not contain those configurations.

Bring your expected annual mileage, fuel-price assumptions and cargo requirements when comparing two candidates. Check access to the bed, cab comfort and parking fit during your visit. Choose the truck whose condition, capability and total budget work together for your needs.

Sources and further reading

Explore your next step

← Back to all guides

Picasso Imports · Virtual assistant

Your next car starts here

Vehicle search, financing, trade-ins and service.

Welcome to Picasso Imports! What kind of car are you looking for?